Sweet Natalie's Menu
Online Ordering Not Currently Available
Check Back For When Online Ordering Will Be Available Again
DF = Dairy Free, V = Vegan, P = Paleo
All Items Are Gluten Free
Candy Items
TRUFFLES $2.50
No Whey Truffles, DF, V
Fudge
Mocha
Free Of All 8 Top Allergens
KRISPY TREATS $5.50
Chocolate Covered Krispy Treats
Different Themed Treats Available
Produced In A Nut Free Facility
Baked Goodies
LEMON BAR $4.99
Lemon Dessert Bars
Large dessert bars that are buttery and lemony with a healthy sprinkle of powdered sugar.
GIANT BROWNIES $5.99
Extra Large Brownies, DF, V
S'mores, peanut butter explosion, and cookie dough are common offerings.
7 LAYER BAR $4.99
Colossal Cookie Bar
A graham crust layered with nuts, chocolate, coconut and more chocolate.
CAKE SLICES $8.99
Flavors Vary Each Week , DF, V
Giant cake slices often available. Famous for our chocolate turtle cake drizzled with caramel.
CUPCAKES $3.99
DF & V Options Available
Funfetti, red velvet, carrot cake, peanut butter chocolate and more.
BREADS $4.99+
DF Options Available
Brioche style sandwich bread, extra large cinnamon bread, mini lemon bread, buns and biscuits.
CINNAMON ROLL $4.99
Giant Frosted Cinnamon Rolls
Lovely, extra-large cinnamon rolls perfect for breakfast or dessert.
CARAMEL BAR $4.99
Salted Caramel Turtle Bar, DF, V
Dessert bars filled with homemade caramel, pecans, walnuts and chocolate chips.
COOKIES $3.50+
Large Cookies, DF Options
Chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, gingersnap, heart sprinkle sugar cookie and more.
PARTY CAKES $35.00+
Frozen Section, DF & V Options
6" cakes from our frozen section. Various flavors available.
DONUTS 2 PACK $6.00+
Flavors Vary Each Week , DF, V
Strawberry coconut, s'mores and churro donuts are commonly offered.
MULTIPACKS $19.99
Cupcakes, DF & V Options
6 packs of various flavors available in our frozen section - can also be purchased by the dozen.
CHEESECAKE $5.99
Cheesecake Slices
Various flavors of large cheesecake slices available weekly.
DALUCIANOS $3.99+
Frozen Section, DF Options
Ravioli, pizza bread, garlic bread and more available from this famous, local restaurant.
Specialty Items
QWACKERS $5.50
Corn Free, Soy Free, GMO Free
Cute, duck shaped crackers that are delicious and fun to eat.
KETO & PALEO $4.99+
Specialty Orders
Keto and paleo products often available for special orders. Check in store for availability.